Model-based ecological optimization of vertical slot fishways using macroinvertebrates and multispecies fish indicators.

Abstract: Fishway research has long focused on post-establishment assessments to optimize fish passage efficiency. Model-based optimization with the use of hydrodynamic-habitat models (HHMs) has rarely been employed to investigate passage suitability based on key hydraulic variables. In this study, a vertical slot fishway was designed, the hydraulic properties of twelve types that varied by slope, slot width and pool size were simulated using a two-dimensional HHM, and the suitability of macroinvertebrates and of seven fish groups, encompassing various guilds and size classes, was assessed for each fishway type at seven discharge scenarios, ranging from 0.1 m3/s to 1.3 m3/s. Suitability was primarily influenced by water depth. At optimal depths, suitability was fine-tuned by flow velocity to different optima per biotic group based on fixed interplays between discharge, slope and slot width: water depths were higher at high discharges, low slopes and narrow slots; flow velocities were higher at high discharges, high slopes and wide slots. Our ecologically optimal, multispecies, vertical slot fishway, had 5% slope and 30-cm wide slots, with discharges shifting between 0.15 m3/s and 0.6 m3/s to balance the needs of all species and life stages studied. Yet, even this optimal fishway could not guarantee 100% suitability for all species. The overall suitability was moderate (approx. 50–60%), higher at the pools and lower at the slots, and critically influenced by the type of substrate. We conclude that technical fishways cannot be simultaneously ideal for all species and life stages of a river reach/basin, due to the often-contrasting habitat preferences that need to be adapted to fixed interplays of hydraulic conditions. Within these limitations, however, model-based ecological pre-optimization is crucial for optimizing and deploying fishways that will guarantee suitable passage routes for a wide range of species and life stages, ultimately restoring the hydromorphological and ecological connectivity of dammed rivers.     «

Abstract: Fishway research has long focused on post-establishment assessments to optimize fish passage efficiency. Model-based optimization with the use of hydrodynamic-habitat models (HHMs) has rarely been employed to investigate passage suitability based on key hydraulic variables. In this study, a vertical slot fishway was designed, the hydraulic properties of twelve types that varied by slope, slot width and pool size were simulated using a two-dimensional HHM, and the suitability of macro...     »